An annotated bibliography and source book norman e. The genealogy contained in this chapter entails an intellectual history of the concept of transitional justice, a term the author coined in 1991 when observing the transitions of latin america and eastern europe. As transitions to democracy have become more common, transitional justice has become a significant issue in many instances. Essays for the new millennium oxford university press 2014 tranziciona pravda serbian translation of my first book, transitional justice, edicija rec beograd, 2014 humanitys law oxford university press, 2011 paper 20 american society of international law book award 2012 honorable mention. This genealogy frames the last decades of transitional justice by offering three phases that reflect changes in. Global civil society and transitional justice springerlink. In this article, i borrow the term genealogy used by ruti teitel 2005. The genealogy of transitional justice tj danial azman2 abstract drawing from secondary literature and three years of fieldwork in various postconflict societies in africa, asia, europe, and latin america, this article revisits the conceptual development of a term transitional justice tj.
For the broader context and an overview of the genealogy of transitional justice, see ruti g. What is novel about teitels approach is the attempt to provide an overarching approach to understanding issues that arise in and out of transitional justice the book is filled with fresh ideas and interesting, provoking perspectivesessential reading for all those facing the complexities of transition in practice. Ruty teitel, in one of the first extensive books on the subject, defines tj as a concept of justice, intervening in a period of political. This book proposes an idea of transitional justice mechanisms in order to portrait society problems under the democratic transition countries.
Rethinking transitional justice from the bottom up jstor. Nov 08, 2006 the proposed genealogy is structured along multiple lines. Teitel provides a collection of her own essays that embody her evolving reflections on the practice and discourse of transitional justice since her book transitional justice published back in 2000. The author defines transitional justice as a framework to solve the fundamental problems of society, in political flux, through judicial and nonjudicial approaches. The law and politics of contemporary transitional justice. Postwar transitional justice the first phase of a genealogy of transitional justice encompasses the postworld war ii model of justice. An introduction to some issues in transitional justice diva. Ruti g teitel among the most prominent and significant political and legal developments since the end of the cold war is the proliferation of mechanisms for addressing the complex challenges of transition from. Oct 06, 2020 this september marked the 20th anniversary of professor ruti teitel s pathbreaking book, transitional justice. Pdf encyclopedia of transitional justice researchgate. Ruti teitel explores the recurring dilemma of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, yet contending that the law nevertheless plays a profound role in periods of radical change. Traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000. Second, the genealogy is organized largely along a schematic based on the law and politics of the developments associated with the three phases of transitional justice.
Ruti teitel explores the recurring dilemma of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, yet contending that the law nevertheless plays a. Transitional justice 1st edition kieran mcevoy louise. The law and politics of comtemporary transitional justice by. Cornell international law journal world history, a framework proposed for the study of the law and politics of transitional justice. Throughout the book, she examines the ability of different mechanisms aside. Transitional justice, truths, and narratives of violence. This book will be of particular interest for scholars and students of law. The notion of transitional justice comprises the full range of processes and mechanisms associated with a society s attempt to come to term with a legacy of largescale human rights abuses in order to ensure accountability and serve justice. Teitel explores the recurring question of how regimes should respond to evil rule, arguing against the prevailing view favoring punishment, and contending through historical and comparative illustrations that the law nevertheless plays a profound role in periods of radical change. The book, written nearly 20 years ago, set the basis for a groundbreaking field of study, bringing to light important legal, political, and ethical dilemmas such as truth versus justice and reparations for victims versus structural. Transitional justice, it is argued, provides recognition of the rights of victims, promotes.
Published in 2000, the book launched a new fieldtransitional justicethat applied a legal and scholarly framework to the rapid transitions to democracy many countries experienced during the late twentieth century. Transitional justice takes thisquestion to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate. The objective of this course is to introduce students to transitional justice and post conflict accountability redress mechanisms. In 1991, at the time of the soviet collapse and following the latin american transitions to democracy in the 1980s, teitel coined the term transitional justice to account for the selfconscious construction of a distinctive conception of justice associated with periods of radical political change on the heels of past oppressive rule luban 2006. This book has been cited by the following publications. How has latin america pioneered the field of transitional justice tj. Ruti teitel, transitional justice genealogy, 16 harv.
Introduction this article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. Ruti teitel s transitional justice offers a fascinating and pathbreaking approach to transitional justice scholarship. Teitel traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000 provides an interdisciplinary perspective deriving from many different national and regional contexts, and. Born in argentina, professor teitels interest in the topic grew out of the dilemmas confronting that society in the transition out of junta rule. His first book, identity, reconciliation and transitional justice. Pursuing peace by engaging justice in yemen project on. Transitional justice takes this question to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate. For a comprehensive analysis of transitional justice, see ruti g. Sep 17, 2020 rereading ruti teitel s transitional justice makes for an even more moving experience than expected. Her pathbreaking book, transition al justice, examines the twentieth century transitions to democracy in many countries. As outline by ruti teitel, transitional justice evokes many aspirations. Teitel s book examines the legal approaches adopted in 20 thcentury transitions to democracy across the world. Transitional justice in historical perspective 2004 r. Stiefel professor of comparative law, new york law school published by oxford university press inc, united states, new york 2002 isbn 10.
Closing the books transitional justice in historical per. Truth seeking the international center for transitional justice. Oct 01, 1999 this book proposes an idea of transitional justice mechanisms in order to portrait society problems under the democratic transition countries. Kluwer press 2002 transitional justice as liberal narrative, in transnational legal processes. Contemporary essays, oxford university press 2014, 6365. Dec 01, 2015 though i have yet to read all the essays, one in particular stands out as an important contributionchapter 4, transitional justice genealogy. Gay men, jews and transitional justice, in gender in transitional justice. Transitional justice, restorative justice and reconciliation. The transitional justice models and the justifications of means of. The genealogy contained in this chapter entails an intellectual history of the concept of transitional justice, a term the author coined in 1991 when observing. Summary of transitional justice beyond intractability.
This list is generated based on data provided by crossref. Transitional justice genealogy, harvard human rights journal. What is novel about teitel s approach is the attempt to provide an overarching approach to understanding issues that arise in and out of transitional justice the book is filled with fresh ideas and interesting, provoking perspectivesessential reading for all those facing the complexities of transition in practice. This essay establishes a useful and interesting periodization of the practice of transitional justice, all the more interesting since the author is one of the principal architects of the field. This article proposes a genealogy of transitional justice. The law and politics of comtemporary transitional justice. Teitel takes an interdisciplinary approach to examine key debates surrounding transitional justice problems. Ruti teitel has outlined a threestage transitional justice genealogy. The politics of transitional justice in latin america. Lia kent, transitional justice and peacebuilding, in an introduction to transitional justice, olivera simic, ed.
Today, criminal responsibility for grave human rights violations is no longer just a matter of postconflict accountability. Transitional justice, it is argued, provides recognition of the rights of victims, promotes civic trust, and strengthens the democratic rule of law. Oct 27, 2020 ruti teitel, globalizing transitional justice. Ruti teitel, transitional justice genealogy, harvard law school human rights journal 16 2003. Teitel 2002, trade paperback at the best online prices at ebay.
This book integrates the actions of this international cooperative project by the amnesty commission. A video tribute to ruti teitel from justice albie sachs this week we are hosting another great online symposium, this time on the 20th anniversary of ruti teitel s seminal book, transitional justice, oup, 2000. Truth and reconciliation commission of south africa, 1998. Provides an interdisciplinary perspective deriving from many different national and regional contexts, and spanning the range of institutions and policy responses. Traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional. Reviewed by bronwyn leebaw transitional justice has been characterized as the choices made and the quality of justice rendered when new leaders replace authoritarian predecessors presumed responsible for criminal acts. First, it is organized chronologically, illustrating critical cycles divided into three phases of transitional justice. Transitional justice is the conception of justice associated with periods of political change, characterized by legal responses to confront the wrongdoings of repressive predecessor regimes.
However, the history begins earlier in the century, following world war i. Harvard human rights journal harvard human rights journal. Transitional justice is a response to systematic or widespread violations of human rights. Cardozo law school, yeshiva university, revisits the trials of the postworld war ii era, above all nuremberg, and explores their legacy for transitional justice in our own times. Nuremburg and tokyo represent an extraordinary foundational stage. Buy transitional justice illustrated by teitel, ruti isbn. Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter. Sep 15, 2020 among transitional justice s many virtues, i want to focus on one that stands out as a reason to keep returning to the book, even when not working strictly within the field of transitional justice. Teitel traces the evolution of the authors reflections on the field of transitional justice since the publication of her book transitional justice oup 2000 provides an interdisciplinary perspective deriving from many different national and regional contexts, and spanning the range of institutions and policy responses. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The encyclopedia of transitional justice, which offers 287 entries written by 166 scholars and practitioners drawn from diverse jurisdictions, includes detailed country studies. This element describes latin american innovations in trials and truth commissions, and evaluates two influential models that explain variation in tj outcomes. This chapter, originally written for a symposium on nuremberg at the benjamin n. Mar 28, 2002 transitional justice takes this question to a new level with an interdisciplinary approach that challenges the very terms of the contemporary debate.
Book description scholars and practitioners working in transitional justice are concerned with remedies of accountability and redress in the aftermath of conflict and state repression. International law scholars honor professor ruti teitels. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. This chapter proposes a genealogy of transitional justice.
169 1432 1699 608 246 1342 719 712 1064 1299 964 1275 1660 31 1715 1367 1112 750 1230 1551 1 951 1073 894 134 147 1346 450 1354 1151 393 1022 40 201 1434